| 
                                 
                                   
                                
                                  
  | 1 | 
  Petals connate 4.5-10 mm (1/2 their lengths); cyme branches often twisted at base (flowers on underside); pedicels pendent, declined, spreading, or ascending to erect in flower, usually bent sharply upward from near middle in fruit; rosettes solitary, 5-60 cm diam., blade often chalky white | 
    | 
  (2) | 
 
  | + | 
  Petals connate 1-3(-4.5) mm (to 1/3 their lengths); cyme branches not twisted (flowers on topside); pedicels ascending to erect in flower, not bent in fruit; rosettes 1-300, 0.8-35 cm diam., blade pale to bright green or blue-green, gray-blue, or gray-green, sometimes becoming purplish or reddish | 
    | 
  (3) | 
 
  |   | 
    | 
    | 
    | 
 
  | 2 (1) | 
  Caudices 1-4 cm diam.; rosettes 10-35-leaved, blade apices acute or usually long-acuminate; pedicels erect or ascending; petals red to apricot yellow; desert mountains. | 
    | 
  20 Dudleya arizonica | 
 
  | + | 
  Caudices 4-10 cm diam.; rosettes 30-80-leaved, blade apices acuminate to cuspidate; pedicels declined or pendent; petals red; coastal side of mountains. | 
    | 
  21 Dudleya pulverulenta | 
 
  |   | 
    | 
    | 
    | 
 
  | 3 (1) | 
  Caudices with axillary branches; unripe follicles ascending; calyces 3-4 × 5.5-7 mm. | 
    | 
  7 Dudleya stolonifera | 
 
  | + | 
  Caudices simple or branching apically, axillary branches absent; unripe follicles erect; calyces 3-9 × 3-9 mm | 
    | 
  (4) | 
 
  |   | 
    | 
    | 
    | 
 
  | 4 (3) | 
  Rosettes 10-30 cm diam., 20-45-leaved; caudices simple, 2-8 cm diam.; leaf blades usually not farinose, 3-7 cm wide; insular. | 
    | 
  13 Dudleya candelabrum | 
 
  | + | 
  Rosettes usually 1-15(-35) cm diam., 5-25(-65)-leaved; caudices simple or branched, 0.5-3.5 cm diam.; leaf blades sometimes farinose, usually to 3 cm wide, rarely to 6 cm; mainland and insular | 
    | 
  (5) | 
 
  |   | 
    | 
    | 
    | 
 
  | 5 (4) | 
  Leaves withering in early summer; cymes mostly 2-4-branched | 
    | 
  (6) | 
 
  | + | 
  Leaves persistent; cymes usually 1-6-branched | 
    | 
  (7) | 
 
  |   | 
    | 
    | 
    | 
 
  | 6 (5) | 
  Petals pale or bright yellow, mustard yellow, or red, apex mostly narrowly acute; pedicels 5-15 mm; leaf blades 0.5-1.2 cm wide | 
    | 
  8 Dudleya cymosa (in part) | 
 
  | + | 
  Petals pale yellow, sometimes red-lineolate, apex broadly acute; pedicels 1-3 mm; leaf blades 0.3-0.7 cm wide | 
    | 
  10 Dudleya parva | 
 
  |   | 
    | 
    | 
    | 
 
  | 7 (5) | 
  Caudices usually 10-60 cm; rosette leaf blades usually 3-8 mm thick | 
    | 
  (8) | 
 
  | + | 
  Caudices usually 0.1-10 cm; rosette leaf blades 1-6 mm thick | 
    | 
  (11) | 
 
  |   | 
    | 
    | 
    | 
 
  | 8 (7) | 
  Corollas loosely tubular, free margins of each petal usually not connivent to adjacent petals, petals pale yellow; rosette leaf blades ovate-oblong. | 
    | 
  14 Dudleya farinosa | 
 
  | + | 
  Corollas tightly 5-gonal, free margins of each petal usually connivent to adjacent petals, petals whitish, pale yellow, or bright yellow to orange or red; rosette leaf blades oblong or oblong-lanceolate to oblong-obovate | 
    | 
  (9) | 
 
  |   | 
    | 
    | 
    | 
 
  | 9 (8) | 
  Petals pale yellow or whitish, 8-12 mm, tips sometimes out- curved; insular. | 
    | 
  15 Dudleya greenei | 
 
  | + | 
  Petals bright yellow to orange or red, 8-16 mm, tips erect; insular or mainland | 
    | 
  (10) | 
 
  |   | 
    | 
    | 
    | 
 
  | 10 (9) | 
  Rosette leaf blades 0.5-4 cm wide; petals mostly bright yellow to red. | 
    | 
  18 Dudleya cespitosa | 
 
  | + | 
  Rosette leaf blades 1.5-5 cm wide; petals red or bright yellow marked with red and appearing orange | 
    | 
  19 Dudleya palmeri | 
 
  |   | 
    | 
    | 
    | 
 
  | 11 (7) | 
  Pedicels usually 5-20 mm | 
    | 
  (12) | 
 
  | + | 
  Pedicels usually 1-6(-17) mm | 
    | 
  (13) | 
 
  |   | 
    | 
    | 
    | 
 
  | 12 (11) | 
  Rosette leaf blades usually oblanceolate to spatulate, rhombic-oblanceolate, oblong, elliptic, ovate, or sometimes triangular-oblong, 1.5-12(-17) × 0.5-6 cm, apex acute to acuminate or cuspidate or subobtuse; petal apices narrowly acute; cyme branches simple or 1-3 times bifurcate; cincinni 1-5(-17) cm. | 
    | 
  8 Dudleya cymosa (in part) | 
 
  | + | 
  Rosette leaf blades oblong-lanceolate, 3-15 × 0.5-2.5 cm, apex narrowly acute; petal apices acute; cyme branches simple or bifurcate; cincinni 1-18 cm. | 
    | 
  12 Dudleya saxosa | 
 
  |   | 
    | 
    | 
    | 
 
  | 13 (11) | 
  Petals pale yellow or straw yellow to medium yellow or almost white (rarely bright yellow) and often red-lineolate, 1.5-4.5 mm wide; rosette leaf blades 0.6-6(-11) × 0.2-2 cm; floral shoots 2-25 cm | 
    | 
  (14) | 
 
  | + | 
  Petals bright yellow to usually red, 2.5-5 mm wide; rosette leaf blades 2-30 × 0.4-4 cm; floral shoots (3-)15-120 cm | 
    | 
  (15) | 
 
  |   | 
    | 
    | 
    | 
 
  | 14 (13) | 
  Rosette leaves linear or elliptic to oblong-lanceolate or tapering from base; cincinni 3-15 cm. | 
    | 
  9 Dudleya abramsii | 
 
  | + | 
  Rosette leaves triangular-ovate; cincinni 1-3 cm. | 
    | 
  16 Dudleya gnoma | 
 
  |   | 
    | 
    | 
    | 
 
  | 15 (13) | 
  Caudices 1-3 cm diam.; leaf blade bases 1-3 cm wide. | 
    | 
  11 Dudleya lanceolata | 
 
  | + | 
  Caudices 0.2-1 cm diam.; leaf blade bases 0.5-0.8 cm wide. | 
    | 
  17 Dudleya verityi | 
 
 
 
                               |